Jenny Lanctot, of recent Evidentia webinars and hangouts fame, posted You Can Trust a Genealogist Relative, Right? on her blog Are My Roots Showing? Jenny's answer to that question is well taken on multiple counts:
1. Always revisit another researcher's work before incorporating it into your own.
2. Regarding extracts: What one person thinks is important might not be what you think important.
3. Without a copy of the original document you cannot be sure the previous researcher, indexer, abstracter or or transcriber didn't make a mistake. We are all human.
4.Transcribe every document word-for-word, even if it is typed, as a prelude to analysis of the claims or inferences that can be drawn from the information provided.
5. The software program Evidentia encourages document analysis. It is all about looking at a document, then analyzing what the document claims about individuals who may or may not end up being an ancestor. Evidentia summary reports are easily copied and pasted into notes for a specific event or fact in an ancestor's profile in a traditional genealogy management program.
Happy family tree climbing!
Your friend in genealogy.
G+ DearMYRTLE Community
Second Life: Clarise Beaumont